Microsoft Says Next Windows Won’t Be As Annoying

Comments

[this is good]
I think stability wise, it is better than it used to be...
My argument would be that need to redo the filesystem to begin with. I think biggest problem is that Windows filesystems (FAT, NTFS) are strict-locking type of filesystem, which means users can't hotswap the file, which means software changes requires reboot, even if it not a software.

I think the biggest problem of Windows is that it is designed in a way so people can't do stupid thing with it; like deleting files while application is using them, for example. Linux allows that as image of the executables and libraries are loaded on the memory during its execution. (of course, if critical file are lost during execution, then subsequent execution won't work; and will make the system unbootable if critical system is deleted or moved this way.)

It is certainly annoying, that many "userland" programs would still requires full system reboot; and some of them even don't need reboot technically; mere restart of explorer.exe will do, but I think it's just that stupidity factor that coming in, again.

Personally, I like the way Linux handles this. The way Windows do this is annoying as hell.
Reading this Wikipedia article on file locking in Windows, it seems that Windows does support less strict file locking, like UNIX, but uses strict file locking by default. It says that strict locking by default is done for compatibility reasons for MS-DOS programs.

One way Windows could be less annoying would be if it reported on which processes locked a particular file. There is this tool called handle which I use when I need to find (and usually quit or kill) the process locking a file. It would be better if instead of "Access Denied" you got back something like "Application Process Outlook has locked this file for read-write access.".

The problem with Windows (and UNIX often) is it will tell you you can't do something, but never why you can't do something.
I agree. Yeah, those sysinternal tools are quite useful.
I don't see any reason Microsoft can't implement feature like handle built into the system!

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in

genman

About Me

genman
United States
Outdoor otaku - is this possible?

My Groups

Neighborhood

Explore friends, family, friends & family, or entire neighborhood.

Archives